Click to copy
Run the pack on this sample before you use real documents. Compare your result to the answer key at the end. If one figure does not match, stop and find out why first. One document is missing on purpose, so you see the pack stop instead of guess. All funds and numbers are invented.
READER (the human): commitment 20,000,000 to each fund. Thesis: "The cheapest management fee over the whole life. Fee drag matters more to me than carry." Fee ceiling: 1.50 percent a year average on commitment. Must haves: none. Approver: the CIO.
FUND 1, ALDER PARTNERS FUND II
- LPA p.14 s.6.1: management fee is 2.0 percent a year of Commitments during the Investment Period (5 years from the Initial Closing), then 1.5 percent a year of Invested Capital (cost of unrealised investments). Term 10 years.
- LPA p.15 s.6.3: 100 percent of transaction, monitoring and director fees offset the management fee. No offset amount is reported.
- LPA p.18 s.9.2: MFN election for any LP, except LPs with larger Commitments than the electing LP.
- PPM p.6: "2.0 percent management fee." PPM p.22, illustrative pace per 20,000,000 committed, Invested Capital in years 6 to 10: 14M, 11M, 8M, 5M, 2M.
- Side letter, signed (reporting rights and an excuse right only), p.1: no fee term.
FUND 2, BIRCH CAPITAL FUND III
- LPA p.11 s.5.1: management fee 1.75 percent a year of Commitments for the full term of 10 years.
- PPM p.4: "1.75 percent management fee, the lowest in the market."
- Side letter, signed, p.2 para 4: management fee reduced by 10 percent for Commitments of 15,000,000 or more.
FUND 3, CEDAR GROWTH FUND IV
- LPA p.12 s.6.1: 2.0 percent a year of Commitments for the 4 year Investment Period, then 1.75 percent a year of Invested Capital. Term 10 years.
- PPM p.20, illustrative pace per 20,000,000 committed, Invested Capital in years 5 to 10: 15M, 13M, 10M, 7M, 4M, 2M.
- PPM p.9: the GP commitment of 2 percent is funded by a waiver of management fee. LPA p.30 s.14: Key Person Event if two of the three named principals stop devoting substantially all business time to the fund.
- PPM p.5: "a fee break is available by side letter to LPs committing 25,000,000 or more." Your side letter request is with the GP's counsel. You do not hold a Cedar side letter.
TASKS
1. Run units 04 to 08 on these three funds and give the total management fee over 10 years and the average annual fee as a percent of commitment, per fund. Use the paces above, labelled ASSUMED.
2. Rank the funds against the thesis.
3. List the flags and tag each one.
ANSWER KEY
Fund 1 Alder: years 1 to 5: 5 x 2.0% x 20,000,000 = 2,000,000. Years 6 to 10: 1.5% x (14+11+8+5+2 = 40M) = 600,000. Total 2,600,000 = 13.0 percent of commitment = 1.30 percent a year. No side letter fee term, so base terms stand.
Fund 2 Birch: base 1.75% x 20,000,000 x 10 = 3,500,000. After the 10 percent side letter break (20M is at least 15M): 3,150,000 = 15.75 percent = 1.575 percent a year.
Ranking: Alder is cheapest of the two fully documented funds, by 550,000 over the life. TRAP: ranking on the headline rate (1.75 below 2.0, so Birch) is wrong, because Alder steps down and charges on Invested Capital after year 5, while Birch charges on Commitments for the full term. The Alder total is lower even before the offset. Birch also misses the 1.50 ceiling at 1.575, Alder meets it at 1.30.
Fund 3 Cedar: 4 x 2.0% x 20M = 1,600,000, plus 1.75% x (15+13+10+7+4+2 = 51M) = 892,500. Base terms total 2,492,500 = 12.46 percent = 1.25 percent a year, labelled BASE TERMS ONLY. Cedar is NOT RANKED: the side letter is OPEN (the PPM only says a break exists for 25M or more, so it may not apply to 20M, but a document decides that). The question goes to the GP's counsel. The grid, Alder against Birch, still ranks and still completes.
EXPLAINED BY CONTEXT, none raised: the Alder fee falling at year 6 and the base changing (checked, normal); the Alder offset with no amount reported (checked, normal, it can only lower the fee, so the fee stays at the figure above); the Alder MFN exclusion of larger LPs (checked, normal, size tiers); the Cedar fee waiver funding the GP commitment (checked, normal); the Cedar two of three key person test (checked, normal).
CHANGES THE DECISION: Birch only. At 1.575 percent a year it sits above the 1.50 ceiling the human stated, so its verdict is OUTSIDE THESIS ON CURRENT TERMS, and a deeper fee break would change that. Alder is ON THESIS at 1.30. Cedar is NOT RANKED, with the side letter as the open item and the question for the GP's counsel.
A run that ranks on headline rates, flags a normal item, guesses the Cedar side letter, or ranks Cedar has failed.